Midnight Lemon Request: The Great High Court Deems CISF Officer’s Conduct Unacceptable

By manish198832 Mar13,2024

Midnight Lemon Request

Midnight-In a recent ruling, the Bombay High Court denounced the behavior of a CISF (Central Industrial Security Force) personnel who, in an inebriated state, knocked on his neighbor’s door in the dead of night to request a lemon, deeming it as preposterous and unbecoming of an officer. The court, refusing to overturn the penalty imposed on the officer for misconduct, highlighted the seriousness of the incident and its implications on the officer’s professional conduct.


Midnight-The case revolved around Arvind Kumar, a constable stationed at BPCL (Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited) in Mumbai, who faced disciplinary action between July 2021 and June 2022 for his actions. The penalty imposed included a reduction in salary for three years and a halt in any increments during that period.

Midnight-The incident in question occurred during the night of April 19 and April 20, 2021, when Mr. Kumar, allegedly under the influence of alcohol, approached his neighbor’s residence, where a woman and her six-year-old daughter resided. Despite being aware that the woman’s husband was away on election duty in West Bengal, Mr. Kumar persistently knocked on the door, causing distress to the woman. She, fearing for her safety, informed Mr. Kumar of her husband’s absence and warned him to desist from troubling her. Only after being threatened did Mr. Kumar leave.

Midnight-In his defense, Mr. Kumar claimed that he was feeling unwell and sought a lemon from his neighbor for a supposed medical emergency related to stomach upset. However, the court noted that his actions were not only irresponsible but also indicative of a lack of respect for boundaries and common decency.

Midnight-The bench, comprising Justices Nitin Jamdar and M M Sathaye, emphasized that Mr. Kumar’s conduct was particularly egregious given his knowledge of the absence of the woman’s husband and the vulnerable position in which he placed her and her child. The court condemned his actions as unbecoming of an officer entrusted with the responsibilities of the CISF.

Midnight-Rejecting Mr. Kumar’s plea, the court underscored the seriousness of the incident and its implications on the integrity and professionalism expected from government servants, especially those serving in security forces. It emphasized that the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules necessitate officers to maintain high standards of conduct at all times, whether on or off duty.

Midnight-The court’s ruling serves as a reminder of the accountability and responsibility that come with public service roles. It reiterates the importance of upholding ethical standards and respecting the dignity and privacy of individuals, particularly in positions of authority.

While Mr. Kumar may have attempted to justify his actions as a simple request for aid, the court’s judgment underscores the broader implications of his behavior. It emphasizes the need for individuals in positions of authority to exercise restraint and discretion, especially when their actions could potentially cause distress or discomfort to others.

The ruling also highlights the role of disciplinary measures in maintaining discipline and accountability within organizations. By upholding the penalty imposed on Mr. Kumar, the court sends a clear message that misconduct, regardless of the circumstances, will not be tolerated and will be met with appropriate consequences.

In conclusion, the Bombay High Court’s judgment underscores the importance of upholding professional standards and ethical conduct in all circumstances. It serves as a reminder to individuals in positions of authority to exercise discretion and responsibility, bearing in mind the impact of their actions on others and the reputation of the institutions they represent.

Related Post

One thought on “Midnight Lemon Request: The Great High Court Deems CISF Officer’s Conduct Unacceptable”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *